Johnston & Murphy Shoes Review – 2023 Best Picks

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Review

Disclosure: Heads up, savvy reader! My name is Tim Schroeder. Your favorite shoe expert. Clicking on our links could lead you to fantastic finds, and it might even make my day a little brighter with a small commission. Win-win! Just so you know, the sneakerheads here at LearnAboutShoes make every effort to test and thoroughly research the products we recommend. Enjoy the article!

Johnston & Murphy has been in the shoe game for over 170 years, so it’s no surprise that they know a thing or two about craftsmanship.

The Johnston & Murphy brand is synonymous with quality, and their dress shoes are some of the most popular on the market.

Johnston & Murphy shoes are not only stylish, but they are also incredibly comfortable, and they can be worn for just about any occasion.

Whether you’re looking for a new pair of dress shoes to wear to work or you need a new pair of boots to take on your next outdoor adventure, Johnston & Murphy has you covered.

In this Johnston & Murphy shoes review, we’ll take a closer look at what makes these shoes so unique and see if they’re worth the investment. We’ll also give you our thoughts on why you should consider adding a few pairs of Johnston & Murphy shoes to your wardrobe.

How Did Johnston & Murphy Get Started?

How Did Johnston & Murphy Get Started?

Johnston & Murphy has been in the business of making shoes since 1850. Earlier, it was known as the William J. Dudley Shoe Company. It started in Newark, New Jersey, and soon became one of America’s most popular shoe brands.

It went on to be known as The James Johnston Company, and then finally, in 1882, they teamed up with William Murphy, who became a partner in the business. The company was later named Johnston & Murphy.

The company prospered and began to make shoes for both men and women. In addition, they developed new styles and techniques, including the use of the Goodyear welt method, which is still used today.

Today, Johnston & Murphy remains a leader in the shoe industry, offering a wide array of styles. Their shoes are still made using the same high-quality materials and techniques that have made them a favorite among consumers for over 170 years.

Browse Shoes by Johnston & Murphy

Johnston & Murphy – 170+ Years Of Shoe Excellence

Johnston & Murphy became known for their high-quality shoes and were even commissioned to make shoes for President Teddy Roosevelt, J.F. Kennedy, and many other celebrities.

If you’re looking for a quality pair of shoes, Johnston & Murphy is a brand you can trust. They have a lot of experience in the shoe business, and their shoes are made with only the highest-quality materials.

Plus, their styles are always up-to-date, so you’ll never have to worry about looking outdated. Johnston & Murphy is an excellent choice for anyone who wants a good pair of shoes that will last.

What Can You Buy on The Johnston & Murphy Website?

Johnston & Murphy is a premium American footwear brand.

Johnston & Murphy’s shoes are known for their high-quality construction and classic style. The company offers an extensive range of shoes for men and women, including dress shoes, casual shoes, boots, and more.

In recent years, the company has expanded its offerings to include clothing and accessories, but its shoes remain the core of its business.

Johnston & Murphy also offers several exclusive collections, such as the limited-edition Johnston & Murphy Signature Collection.

Why Are Johnston & Murphy Shoes So Popular?

Johnston & Murphy footwear is popular for several reasons:

  1. First, they are known for their quality craftsmanship. Johnston & Murphy has been making shoes since 1850, and their experience shows in the construction of their shoes. They use only the finest materials, and their shoes are built to last.
  2. Secondly, Johnston & Murphy offers different styles to choose from. So whether you’re looking for dress shoes or casual shoes, you’re sure to find a pair that suits your taste.
  3. Finally, Johnston & Murphy’s customer service is top-notch. If you have any problems with your purchase, they will be more than happy to help you out.

If you haven’t tried Johnston & Murphy footwear yet, get your first pair today!

Best Johnston & Murphy Shoes For Men Review

In the world of men’s shoes, Johnston & Murphy is a very well-known and respected brand. Here are some of my favorite pairs of Johnston & Murphy shoes and my thoughts on them.

1. Amherst Knit U-Throat Sneakers

Johnston & Murphy sneakers review

Looking for a great pair of Johnston & Murphy sneakers? Check out the Amherst Knit U-Throat! These shoes are lightweight, cushioned, and perfect for everyday wear.

They also feature J&M Smart Degree Technology®, which keeps your feet comfortable all day long. Plus, the removable footbed allows you to customize your fit.

So if you’re looking for a pair of comfortable shoes, be sure to check out the Amherst Knit U-Throat!

2. McGuffey Slip-On

Looking for a comfortable and stylish slip-on? The McGuffey Slip-On from Johnston & Murphy might be just what you’re looking for!

With updated textures and styles, this shoe is perfect for any occasion. Plus, the cushioning adds comfort, while the sheepskin performance-mesh cover keeps your feet cool and dry.

Stretch gores make on/off a breeze, and the rubber sole provides durability. So don’t wait – order your McGuffey Slip-On today!

3. XC4® H2-Luxe Hybrid Saddle

Johnston & Murphy XC4 H2 Luxe Saddle Golf Shoes

Looking for a durable and comfortable hybrid saddle with laces? Look no further than the Johnston & Murphy XC4® H2-Luxe! This saddle is perfect for those who want the best of both worlds – a saddle that is both comfortable and stylish.

The waterproof feature ensures your feet stay dry, while the Smart Degree Technology® keeps them at just the right temperature all day long.

The dual-width footbed can be easily removed to accommodate your own orthotic or wide foot, and the triple-density footbed with memory foam cushioning provides superior comfort and arch support.

With a lightweight, shock-absorbing midsole and hybrid lug sole, this saddle is perfect for those who love to ride!

4. McGuffey GL2 Hybrid Plain Toe

Looking for a great pair of shoes that can be used for both golf and everyday wear? Look no further than the Johnston & Murphy McGuffey GL2 Hybrid Plain Toe Shoes!

These shoes are made with waterproof construction, making them perfect for wet weather. They also come with a hybrid-lug rubber sole, providing you with superior performance on the green.

And to top it all off, they come with an exclusive TRUFOAM footbed that provides incredible cushioning and comfort. So don’t go another day without the perfect pair of shoes – purchase a pair of Johnston & Murphy McGuffey GL2 Hybrid Plain Toe Shoes today!

5. Copeland Chukka Boots

Looking for a stylish and comfortable pair of boots? Look no further than Johnston & Murphy’s Copeland Chukka.

These boots are made of premium, water-resistant leather or oiled suede and feature sheepskin lining and memory foam cushioning to ensure your feet stay comfortable all day long. Plus, the genuine crepe rubber sole provides excellent traction and durability.

Whether you’re pairing them with jeans or chinos, Johnston & Murphy’s Copeland Chukka is an excellent choice for any man who wants to look sharp and feel comfortable at the same time. So don’t wait any longer; order your pair today!

6. Cort Shearling Slipper

Johnston & Murphy Cort Shearling Slipper for Men

Looking for a comfortable and stylish slipper? Johnston & Murphy has the perfect solution with their Cort Shearling Slipper.

Made with rich full-grain leather and a luxurious shearling lining, this slipper will keep your feet warm all winter long. With a removable footbed and full EVA sole, you can wear these slippers indoors or out.

Johnston & Murphy’s commitment to quality craftsmanship is evident in the hand-sewn detail of this slipper. Give your feet the Johnston & Murphy treatment with the Cort Shearling Slipper.

7. Newport Perfed Thong

Looking for a comfortable and stylish flip-flop? Look no further than the Newport Perfed Thong from Johnston & Murphy.

This sporty flip-flop is perfect for summer, with its pop-color accents and contrast color neoprene-lined strap. The cushioned EVA footbed ensures hours of comfort, while the contrast color rubber sole provides excellent traction.

Whether you’re hitting the beach or just running errands, the Newport Perfed Thong is a great choice.

8. Melton Cap Toe Dress Shoes

Johnston & Murphy Melton Cap Toe Dress Shoe for Men

Looking for a comfortable and stylish dress shoe? Johnston & Murphy has you covered. With hand-selected European leather, the Melton Cap Toe Dress Shoe is sure to make you look and feel your best.

The exclusive Optima Comfort System provides optimal comfort, support, and flexibility, while the leather lining with perforated forefoot enhances breathability.

The leather soles and combination of stacked leather/Fineline rubber heels give a clean, dressy appearance, and the Goodyear welt construction allows the leather to mold to your foot for a truly individual fit.

Get a classic look with the Melton Cap Toe Dress Shoes!

9. Fairfax Slip-On

Looking for a Johnston & Murphy formal shoe? Look no further! The Fairfax Slip-On is perfect for any formal occasion.

Made of genuine patent leather, this minimalist dress slip-on features grosgrain trim and stretch gore.

A full calfskin lining ensures hours of comfortable wear, while a memory-foam cushioned footbed provides unmatched support.

Finished with a leather sole, the Fairfax Slip-On will take your style to the next level. Johnston & Murphy provides nothing but the best, so you can be sure you’re getting a quality product.

Best Johnston & Murphy Shoes For Women Review

Johnston & Murphy is a trusted name in shoes, and their women’s shoes are some of the best on the market. Here are some of my favorite pairs for women.

1. Callie Slip-On

Looking for a versatile shoe that can be dressed up or down? Johnston & Murphy has you covered with their Callie Slip-On. Made of luxe leather and featuring TRUFOAM™ cushioning, this sneaker is perfect for all-day comfort.

The stretch gore inside ensures a snug fit, while the calfskin lining provides a luxurious feel. Plus, the genuine leather welt ensures durability, and the 1″ rubber sole provides traction.

2. Trista Mule

Johnston & Murphy Trista Mule Shoes

Johnston & Murphy shoes are a classic American brand known for their comfort and quality, and their Trista Mule is no exception.

This chic and comfortable slip-on features a clean design with a block heel, making it perfect for everyday wear.

The leopard-print haircalf or Italian leather and suede upper adds a touch of luxury, while the Ortholite®-cushioned footbed ensures all-day comfort.

The flexible sole with textured rubber insets provides traction, making these mules perfect for both work and play.

3. Maggie Kiltie Tassel

Looking for a comfortable and stylish driving shoe? Johnston & Murphy has you covered with their Maggie Kiltie Tassel shoes.

Made with a genuine handsewn moccasin construction, these shoes feature a soft calfskin lining and cushioned footbed for all-day comfort. They also have a hidden wedge midsole for extra lift and cushioning, as well as J&M Flex technology to ensure a perfect fit.

Plus, the rubber driver-style pod sole provides durability and traction on any surface. So whether you’re driving or just running errands, the Johnston & Murphy Maggie Kiltie Tassel shoes are a great choice.

4. Zoey Braided Thong

Johnston & Murphy Zoey Braided Thong Sandals For Women

Looking for a comfy and stylish sandal? Check out the Zoey Braided Thong from Johnston & Murphy!

These sandals feature soft tubular braided straps, a metallic leather-covered foam-cushioned footbed, and a rubber sole. They’re perfect for summer days spent walking around town or relaxing on the beach.

Plus, they come in a variety of colors to match any outfit. So what are you waiting for? Order your pair today!

5. Evelyn Bootie

Looking for a versatile and comfortable bootie? Look no further than the Johnston & Murphy Evelyn Bootie!

This open-toe leather bootie comes with a comfortable cushioning and easy-to-wear mid-heel. It’s also made of supple glove leather and has an adjustable hook-and-loop fastener strap.

The soft calfskin lining and OrthoLite®-cushioned footbed make it a dream to wear, while the 2½” stacked leather-wrapped heel gives you just the right amount of height. And don’t forget the flexible leather-look sole!

6. Jade Asymmetrical Strap

Looking for a sandal this summer? Look no further than the Johnston & Murphy Jade Asymmetrical Strap.

This sandal features an asymmetrical strap design that provides a flattering and comfortable fit, while the metal hardware adds a touch of elegance.

The calfskin lining ensures your feet stay cool and dry all day long, while the OrthoLite footbed ensures hours-long comfort.

The stacked leather wedge and platform provide plenty of height without sacrificing stability, and the rubber sole ensures you can wear these sandals anywhere without fear of slipping.

7. XC4® Mollie Bootie

Johnston & Murphy XC4 Mollie Boot For Women

Looking for a chic and comfy bootie? Look no further than Johnston & Murphy’s XC4® Mollie Bootie!

This breathable and waterproof shoe is perfect for wet or dry conditions and features an exclusive TRUFOAM™ sole for an incredibly light, bouncy feel.

The Ortholite®-cushioned footbed ensures a dual-width fit, while the faux fur-lined shaft provides extra warmth and comfort. Finished with a metallic leather accent at the back, this bootie is sure to turn heads!

8. XC4® Women’s H1-Sport Hybrid

Looking for a stylish and comfortable golf shoe? Look no further than Johnston & Murphy’s XC4® Women’s H1-Sport Hybrid Golf Shoe.

This waterproof golf shoe is perfect for comfort on or off the course, with features like a breathable waterproof bootie construction, lightweight knit mesh with leather trim, and J&M Smart Degree Technology® temperature-adjusting interior.

The multi-layered cushioned footbed ensures long-lasting comfort, while the removable insole accommodates your own orthotic or wide foot.

You’ll love the padded collar and lightweight EVA midsole for enhanced cushioning, not to mention the rubber hybrid lug sole that provides excellent stability on the greens.

9. Emery Center Gore Sneakers

Johnston & Murphy Emery Center Gore Sneakers For Women

Looking for a lightweight and comfortable sneaker? Look no further than the Emery Center Gore Sneaker from Johnston & Murphy.

This sneaker features a stretch-knit construction that makes it easy to put on and take off, while the leather lining ensures a comfortable fit.

Additionally, the EVA/Ortholite®-cushioned insole provides extra cushioning and support, and the center stretch gore across the instep helps keep your foot secure.

If you feel you want some extra cushioning or arch support, see my article on the best insoles for standing all day or the best insoles for walking.

The leather welt and 1¾” EVA midsole add durability and stability, while the rubber sole provides traction.

Whether you’re running errands or working out, the Emery Center Gore Sneaker is a great choice for active days.

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Vs Other Brands

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Vs Other Brands

Johnston & Murphy is a company that’s been around for over 170 years. It’s one of the oldest shoe brands in America and has a reputation for quality.

But how does Johnston & Murphy stack up against other brands like Cole Haan, Allen Edmonds, and Men’s Wearhouse? I put Johnston & Murphy shoes to the test to find out.

1. Quality

Regarding quality, Johnston & Murphy is on par with other brands. The materials they use are top-notch, and their shoes are built to last. I didn’t have any issues with Johnston & Murphy shoes falling apart or wearing down quickly.

2. Comfort

Johnston & Murphy shoes are also super comfortable. The leather quality is soft, and the soles are cushioned, so you can wear them all day without your feet getting pressure sores.

I did find that Johnston & Murphy shoes run a bit small, so be sure to order a size up if you’re in between sizes.

3. Style

Johnston & Murphy has a wide variety of styles to choose from, so you’re sure to find a pair that fits your taste. In addition, their shoes are classic and timeless, so you’ll be able to wear them for years to come.

4. Price

Johnston & Murphy shoes are on the expensive side, but they’re indeed better than many higher-priced competitors. You’ll be able to wear them for years, and they’ll never go out of style.

Overall, Johnston & Murphy is a great choice for those looking for quality, comfortable, and stylish shoes. Of course, the price can be a top concern, but they’re worth the investment. I give Johnston & Murphy two thumbs up!

How To Clean Your Johnston & Murphy Shoes?

Johnston & Murphy shoes are made of high-quality materials and construction, so it is important to take care of them to ensure they last long.

Here are a few tips on how to care for your Johnston & Murphy shoes:

  • Use a shoehorn – This will help preserve the shape of the back of the shoe and prevent creasing.
  • Stuff shoes with newspaper – This will help absorb moisture and keep their shape while you are not wearing them.
  • Shine your shoes regularly – A good shoe shine will help protect the leather and prolong the life of your shoes.
  • Take them to a cobbler when they need repair – A professional cobbler can extend the life of your Johnston & Murphy shoes.

My article on how to clean leather shoes might also prove helpful.

Following these tips will help you get the most out of your Johnston & Murphy shoes and keep them looking great for years to come.

Johnston & Murphy FAQs

Johnston & Murphy Shoes FAQs

Now that we have taken a look at Johnston & Murphy and their shoes, it is time to answer some frequently asked questions.

1. Where are Johnston & Murphy shoes made?

Most shoes from Johnston & Murphy are made in China.

2. Is Johnston & Murphy a luxury brand?

No, Johnston & Murphy is not a luxury brand but they would be considered a high-end premium shoe brand. They are not a budget shoe brand.

Their shoes are really well made and are sold at a premium price but not near the same prices as luxury shoe brands like Gucci, Jimmy Choo, or Christian Louboutin for example.

3. How much do Johnston & Murphy shoes cost?

Prices for Johnston & Murphy shoes vary depending on the style and type of shoe. However, you can expect to pay between $100-$355 for a pair of Johnston & Murphy dress shoes.

The Johnston & Murphy sandals run in the $50 to $100 range.

4. What are the best websites to buy Johnston & Murphy shoes?

You can purchase their shoes at the following online retailers:

  1. Buy Johnston & Murphy shoes on the company website
  2. Buy Johnston & Murphy shoes on Zappos
  3. Buy Johnston & Murphy shoes on Amazon

5. Are Johnston & Murphy clothes good?

Johnston & Murphy is primarily a footwear company, but the company does offer a small selection of clothing items for men and women. The clothing is of high quality and features the same attention to detail as the shoes.

6. Are Johnston & Murphy real leather shoes?

Johnston & Murphy shoes are made with several materials, including real high-quality leather. Some shoes tend to be made of full-grain leather or suede too. As a result, you can expect your shoes to last for many years with proper care.

7. How often should I polish my Johnston & Murphy shoes?

It is recommended that you polish your Johnston & Murphy shoes every 2-3 weeks to keep them looking their best.

8. I’m having trouble finding my size; what should I do?

If you’re having trouble finding your size, Johnston & Murphy offers a free chart on their website that can help you convert your size to the Johnston & Murphy size.

9. I’m not sure which shoe style I should get; any suggestions?

If you’re not sure which style of shoe to choose, Johnston & Murphy has a helpful “Shop by Occasion” section on their website. Here you can browse shoes for work, formal occasions, casual wear, and more.

Johnston & Murphy Shoes Review – My Final Thoughts

Johnston & Murphy has a long and rich history of crafting quality shoes. Founded in 1850, the company has been committed to creating beautiful, well-made footwear for nearly two centuries.

Today, Johnston & Murphy offers a wide range of stylish shoes for both men and women. From classic oxfords and loafers to trendy sneakers and booties, there’s something for everyone in the Johnston & Murphy collection.

What’s more, Johnston & Murphy shoes are constructed from high-quality materials and are available in a wide range of sizes and widths, so you’re sure to find a perfect fit.

Prices are on the higher end, but Johnston & Murphy shoes are an investment that will last for years to come.

Excellent customer service rounds out my list of reasons to love Johnston & Murphy shoes.

If you’re looking for new shoes that are both stylish and comfortable, Johnston & Murphy is a great option to consider.

If you have any further questions, please feel free to contact me. For our other shoe brand reviews, be sure to check out our blog!

Learn more or buy Johnston & Murphy shoes on the company website
Learn more or buy Johnston & Murphy shoes on Zappos
Learn more or buy Johnston & Murphy shoes on Amazon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.